How To Find The Best Natural Mascara That Actually Works

YOUR EYEBALLS.

They are so important. We must protect them. Letting makeup filled with coal tar and petroleum that’s contaminated with carcinogens, parabens that promote aging and sagging skin, and acne causing ingredients found in airplane deicing liquid drip into your eyeballs is not the answer!

I have to be honest though, I LOVE the way my eyes look when I have makeup on, but I hate the act of putting on makeup, so I do it, grudgingly… And once I found out all the crazy toxic ingredients the makeup industry uses in many conventional products my entire perspective changed. I go days without a lot of makeup on my face unless I’m on camera or have an event. Don’t get me wrong, being on camera has its perks and its disadvantages. It allows me to spread the message of organic, real and non-GMO food living to so many more people, but it also requires heavier makeup at times – those camera lights can be harsh let me tell ya!

When I’m behind the scenes blogging or living my day to day life I wear the least amount of makeup possible – maybe a little blush and lipstain and that’s it. But when I go on camera – it’s eyeliner, eyeshadow and mascara. Mascara was the first makeup product I changed out of my makeup bag, but it took me a long time to figure it out which brands actually work.

Here’s how to find the best natural mascara that actually works.

Slide1

First, let’s talk about the ingredients in mascara you want to avoid:

  • PARABENS - Used as a preservative and is an endocrine disrupter that messes with your hormones. (Top Offenders: L’Oreal, Cover Girl, Avon, Bobbi Brown, Clinique, Maybelline, Neutrogena, Revlon, Chanel, Lancome)

  • PARFUM (a.k.a. fragrance) - Why do you need parfum on your eyes – that’s crazy. Oh it’s to cover up the smell of coal tar! This is even in some products marketed as “unscented.” Some fragrance ingredients can trigger allergies, asthma and acne, linked to cancer and neurotoxicity, and are harmful to fish and other wildlife.  (Top Offenders: Neutrogena, Lavera, Milani)

  • ALUMINUM POWDER - Considered a neurotoxin and linked to Alzheimer’s disease and other cancers. (Top Offenders: Cover Girl, Estee Lauder)

  • BHA and BHT: Used as a preservatives and is an endocrine disruptor and may cause cancer (BHA). Harmful to fish and other wildlife. (Top Offenders: Maybelline, Rimmel)

  • PROPYLENE GLYCOL:  Linked to acne, eczema, and other skin allergies. (Top Offenders: L’Oreal, Mineral Fusion, Rimmel, Avon, Maybelline)

  • COAL TAR DYES: p-phenylenediamine and colours listed as “CI” followed by a five digit number. The U.S. colour name may also be listed (e.g. “FD&C Blue No. 1″ or “Blue 1″). Potential to cause cancer and may be contaminated with heavy metals toxic to the brain. (Top Offender: Maybelline)

  • FORMALDEHYDE RELEASING PRESERVATIVES -  Look for DMDM hydantoin, diazolidinyl urea, imidazolidinyl urea, methenamine and quarternium-15. Used in a variety of cosmetics. Slowly release small amounts of formaldehyde, which causes cancer. (Top Offender: Almay)

  • RETINYL ACETATE (VITAMIN A ACETATE) - Biochemical or cellular level changes, Cancer, Developmental/reproductive toxicity, Organ system toxicity (non-reproductive) (Top Offenders: Elizabeth Arden, Almay, Revlon)

    *Ingredient research provided by The Environmental Working Group and David Suzuki Foundation*

I am a firm believer that if I eat the way I do, I can avoid the impact of most of the chemicals in my surroundings, but I also want to vote with my dollars and I refuse to buy products from companies that continue to pollute the environment and our bodies with loads of toxic substances. I also don’t like the idea that something I put on my eyes can potentially cause cancer over time, cause acne, aging or disrupt my hormonal balance. That’s why I went on a search to find a clean mascara – here are the ones that make the cut that I’ve personally tried… I know there may be some other ones available, but these actually work based on my experience.

Slide2

Food Babe Approved Mascaras

  • Tarte “Lights Camera Lashes” Natural Mascara (Available for $14.99 at Amazon) - This is my absolute favorite mascara, it doesn’t clump or flake over time and it’s easy to wash off with any kind of facial cleanser – especially coconut oil. They also make a waterproof version called “Lights Camera Splashes” (Available for $19.00 at Amazon).

  • Josie Maran (Available for $22.00 at Sephora) - This one feels very luxurious with big volume, especially if you add another coat. 

     

  • Physicians Formula Organic Wear (Available for $11.60 on Amazon) - I like this one because it is available at most drug stores. One time I forgot my makeup bag while I was traveling and found this one at Walgreens – it totally did the trick considering all the other toxic alternatives that were available.

In the end – If you want to know if your makeup is safe and not toxic – check out the Environmental Working Group’s Skin Deep Database, they have thousands of your favorite brands listed with their safety ratings for you to investigate yourself…

Please share this post with all your lady friends – I’m sure they will be very appreciative.

Curl Those Lashes!

Food Babe

P.S. This is my FAVORITE eyelash curler in the whole wide world (I’ve tried them all and this is the best BY FAR!)… and remember to add carrot juice to your green juice, it’s amazing for those eyelashes. When I started doing this, my eyes got brighter and lashes got longer – it’s no joke!

NY Times Photoshoot: Travis Dove Photography
NY Times Photoshoot: Travis Dove Photography

 

food babe subscribe healthy habits icon
Healthy Habits
food babe subscribe left green arrow
Subscribe to Food Babe!
Get a free copy of Food Babe's Healthy Habits, enter amazing product giveaways, and be the first to get the latest blog post.
, , ,
Posts may contain affiliate links for products Food Babe has approved and researched herself. If you purchase a product through an affiliate link, your cost will be the same (or at a discount if a special code is offered) and Food Babe will automatically receive a small referral fee. Your support is crucial because it helps fund this blog and helps us continue to spread the word. Thank you.

252 Responses to “How To Find The Best Natural Mascara That Actually Works”

  1. Kristy

    I tried the Tarte lights Camera Splashes and found it a bit gummy. Anyone else or perhaps did I get a bad batch?

    Reply
    • Jamie (to Kristy)

      I agree it does seem to clump a bit but I respect Food Babe so I will just keep trying until I find one that works. ;)

      Reply
      • Alicia (to Jamie)

        I tried Tarte and absolutely loved it. There is a special technique I was taught by a makeup artist so you don’t get clumping…. I believe it was to use the short side of the brush to coat your lashes, then sweep through with the longer bristles. Hope that helps!

    • Michele (to Kristy)

      Don’t bother using it. The post is a scam. The tartar mascara she’s recommending is actually pretty hazardous stuff. Per Skin deep database.
      You’re better off with Bare Minerals
      http://www.ewg.org/skindeep/product/232265/tarte_lights%2C_camera%2C_lashes%21_mascara%2C_Black/

      Reply
  2. Nicole

    I am a rep for a new naturally based cosmetics company called Younique that has the MOST AMAZING 3D fiber lashes made of collagen and green tea fibers. We have fewer and less harmful ingredients than ANY of the products that were listed on the “Best natural mascaras that work” list. I would love for Food Babe to review these. They will blow your mind. Food Babe or Food Babe assistants, take a look at our link and ingredients list.
    https://www.youniqueproducts.com/products/view/US-1017-00#.UlS7d1BOPZE

    Reply
    • Michele (to Nicole)

      Ooooh, just checked out this site :) Yes, please Food Babe, please do a review on this mascara ~ it looks awesome! I hope it gets your approval!

      Reply
      • Rita Shelton (to Michele)

        I ordered this and I love the look it gives..BUT I have very very sensitive eyes..there was no burning or anything, but after using twice, my whole eyelids started getting red and raw, and they hurt. I can’t even put on eyeshadow..I am putting a cream on to heal them. Has anyone else had this issue..I’m so upset, because it really does look great. It is worth a try. I just can’t use it anymore because of my lids.. :(

    • Elaine (to Nicole)

      Maybe you should send Food Babe your mascara so we can get her reviews.

      Thanks

      Reply
      • Nicole (to Elaine)

        I’ve offered to send her a kit for review. Just waiting to hear back. They are $29 (will last 8-12 weeks with daily use), so I don’t want to just send it without her expecting it :-)

        http://www.youniqueproducts.com/youniquelynicole

      • Nicole (to Elaine)

        Here is the ingredient list of our 3D fiber lashes. Also, there was someone looking for a liner. I take our mineral pigments (talc/paraben free) and wet it for a liner. The only one i have EVER used that didn’t smudge.
        (3D Fiber lashes)
        Transplating Gel Ingredients: collagen, water, natural Propolis, Brazilian palm glue, Black iron oxide, Acrylic Copolymer, Nylon 12, Stearic acid, propylene glycol/emulsifier. Net: 12ml
        Natural fibers Ingredients: 100% natural fibers taken from the campanulaceae of green tea. Net: 3g

      • Trisha (to Elaine)

        Propylene Glycol is NOT natural and is on the toxin list! Go ahead and review it….I would like to hear what she has to say.

    • Hawaiianmojo (to Nicole)

      Propylene glycol & “nylon 12″ ?!? Umm… how is that NATURAL?

      Reply
  3. Linzy

    Hey Food Babe,
    I am a makeup artist trying to use healthier products on myself and my clients. What do you think of Jane Iredale makeup and Origins? They look like better options to me but I’m not sure if I’m missing something? I LOVE Tarte. Do you like all of their products or just the mascara? Thanks!!

    Reply
  4. Johnnie

    I’ve been using Bare Minerals for a while. I have a lot of allergies to makeup & especially eye makeup, but I’ve not had problems with this brand. What do you think about this makeup? Thank you for your help.

    Reply
  5. Jennifer

    I recently bought physicians formula and found that it flakes off very easily. I really want to try the others and don’t mind spending the money if they really work. I wish there was a way to get samples for very cheap or free.

    Reply
    • Michelle (to Jennifer)

      I tried this one too because it was so readily available. Didn’t like it at all.

      I think it makes a difference when you have blonde eyelashes. Food Babe probably has dark ones.

      Reply
  6. Jen

    Dear Food Babe,
    Thank you for the informative posts as always!! I have a follow up question. How long can I keep my mascara? I have heard conflicting answers and was wondering your opinion on this matter. I am someone who does not use mascara daily and so throwing away a pretty much full tube after 2 months seems wasteful to me. Thank you!!!

    Reply
  7. tereska

    I use 100% pure cosmetics and they are ALL ORGANIC AND NATURAL!!! This stuff is amazing and good prices!!

    Reply
    • nunu (to tereska)

      Love 100% Pure’s mascaras and cosmetics! Especially their coloured mascaras. I’ve tried Josie Maran’s mascara, and while I loved the colour and effect it gave my lashes, it also stung my eyes – sephora reviewers seem to have the same problem.

      Reply
  8. Tara

    This is so funny – I was applying makeup the other day, thinking about all the chemicals in it – I know they are there, I have just never really done the research – and I thought, “FoodBabe should totally review makeup products.” I know that you ultimately want US to get off our butts and do the research, but it’s so cool to have a starting place, at least some suggestions of “good ones” for when it’s time to make the decision about what products to buy. There are so many options out there and even the “Natural” makeups are deceiving. Thanks for helping me to sort some of this out!

    Reply
  9. Sally Koskinen

    I use another natural mascara by Arbonne called It’s a Long Story, Love it!!
    So glad you shared this article! Love what you do!

    Reply
    • amy (to Sally Koskinen)

      I also use the Arbonne mascara “Its a Long Story” and I love it! I have used so many types of mascarss (all the brands listed above too, including Jose Maran and Tarte) and have not been happy with the results as they don’t really do much but coat my lashes. After two tubes of Arbonne, my lashes are honestly longer and curlier. Its a little pricey – but worth every long lash!

      Reply
    • Melissa king (to Sally Koskinen)

      I use arbonne as well! Wouldn’t use anything else! Love the article and love how many people are becoming aware of what they put in and on their bodies! http://www.melissaking.myarbonne.com

      Reply
  10. Audrey

    I have used Real Purity’s mascara for years, and I love it! It is rated a “2″ at ewg.org/skindeep.

    Reply
    • Michelle (to Audrey)

      I noticed your strawberry hair. Do you have blonde eyelashes? or know of someone that does and this mascara works on them?

      Reply
      • Audrey (to Michelle)

        Yes, I have very pale lashes and I buy the Sable Brown color. It looks more natural than the black.

      • Audrey (to Michelle)

        Not sure my reply went through, so I’m trying again. My lashes are very pale and I use the Sable Brown. It looks more natural than the black.

  11. Tiana

    I love Melaleuca’s cosmetics, they are all paraben free & nontoxic. The mascara is $12.50, great deal too! :) formaldehyde free nail polish is $8.50. Best deals I’ve found on good quality products.

    Reply
  12. Liz

    Thank you so much for this. Sometimes I almost don’t even want to look into the article, and would rather not know how terrible these products are. But I am always glad once I have looked. Knowledge is definitely power. And considering this is a product that I use almost everyday, I would rather not be using something that could be causing damage to my body. Thank you for bringing light to these issues.

    Reply
  13. Kathy

    There are lots of great clean mascara options—Mineral Fusion, Zuzu, Honeybee Gardens, Dr. Hauschka, to name just a few of my favorites. I’m a bit skeptical about the CDB, though. I’ve seen them rate many products as safe that I wouldn’t use EVER, and I have serious questions about some of the criteria they use.

    Reply
  14. Jane

    Food Babe! You have got to discover Arbonne! You would be so in line with our policies, ethics and tradition. Not to mention, our ‘It’s a long story’ mascara is the best mascara I’ve ever used (toxins or no) it’s as life changing as mascara can be. You should definitely check it out, because I’m surprised and sad to see it’s not on your list ;)

    Reply
    • DWDK (to Jane)

      No reviews on this $39.99 Arbonne (Long Story) mascara on Amazon or anywhere.

      Reply
      • Jane (to DWDK)

        It is one of our newest products. But we are vegan certified and you can read our strict ingredient policy and full product ingredient list on our website :)

    • Food Babe (to Jane)

      Can you please post their list of ingredients – last time I checked it had some of the toxins I mention above in the post. Thanks.

      Reply
      • hawaiianmojo (to Food Babe)

        Thank you food babe for having a place for us to discuss GMO free cosmetics! Especially ones that go on our eyes :) You are APPRECIATED beyond words. Mahalo!

      • Jane (to Food Babe)

        Hey Food Babe! Sorry for the delay, from what I can tell none of your listed ingredients are in this mascara, however you are more of an expert than me on that type of thing, so here you go! (formatting is lost so I apologize if it’s perhaps confusing or hard to read)
        INGREDIENT SOURCE FUNCTION
        Aqua/Water/Eau Solvent
        Iron Oxides (CI 77499) Mineral Colorant
        Glyceryl Stearate Science Emulsifier
        Glycerin Science Hair-conditioning agent
        C18-36 Acid Triglyceride Science Skin-conditioning agent — occlusive
        Synthetic Beeswax Science Binder
        Cera Carnauba/Copernicia Cerifera (Carnauba) Wax/
        Cire de Carnauba
        Plant Emulsifier
        Stearic Acid Science Emulsifier
        Silica Mineral Bulking agent
        VP/VA Copolymer Science Film former
        Acacia Senegal Gum Science Emulsifier
        Butylene Glycol Science Solvent
        Polyglyceryl-10 Diisostearate Science Emulsifier
        PEG-40 Hydrogenated Castor Oil Plant Emulsifier
        ✶ Pisum Sativum (Pea) Extract Plant Skin-conditioning agent
        ✶ Bambusa Vulgaris (Bamboo) Leaf/Stem Extract Plant Skin-conditioning agent
        Xanthan Gum Plant Viscosity agent
        Caprylyl Glycol Science Hair-conditioning agent
        Glyceryl Caprylate Science Skin-conditioning agent
        Sodium Hyaluronate Science Skin-conditioning agent
        ✶ Panthenol (Vitamin B5) Science Hair-conditioning agent
        Ethylhexylglycerin Science Skin-conditioning agent
        PPG-26-Buteth-26 Science Hair-conditioning agent
        ✶ Myristoyl Pentapeptide-17 (Polypeptide) Science Skin-conditioning agent
        ✶ Biotinoyl Tripeptide-1 (Polypeptide) Science Hair-conditioning agent
        Oleanolic Acid Science Skin-conditioning agent
        ✶ Sodium Ascorbyl Phosphate (Vitamin C) Science Antioxidant
        ✶ Tocopheryl Acetate (Vitamin E) Science Antioxidant; skin-conditioning agent
        Apigenin Science Antioxidant; hair-conditioning agent
        Aminomethyl Propanol Science pH adjuster
        Phenethyl Alcohol Science Preservative
        Glucosamine HCl Plant pH adjuster

      • hawaiianmojo (to Food Babe)

        Full toxic ingredient list from arbonne. Note sources of ingredients: http://www.arbonnemarketing.com/PK/dl/pk/7904_us_eng.pdf

      • stacey griffin (to Food Babe)

        Hi there Food Babe! I was really excited to read about the Tarte mascara since it’s your favorite, but became concerned about the rating on EWG (4). There appear to be lots of different parabens in this mascara (namely propylparaben which has a score of 10 on EWG). Have they recently been removed ? (maybe the EWG is not updated). Thanks!

    • hawaiianmojo (to Jane)

      I got an arbonne baby kit “abc kit”, and was disgusted upon receiving it that it had MANY very toxic substances (especially the sunscreen). I would not use it on myself – so heck NO I wouldn’t put it on an infant. TO THE TRASH! IT WENT! Please post the ingredient list of the arbonne mascara that you speak so highly of. I would like to see what I’m considering purchasing this time please.

      Reply
      • Jane (to hawaiianmojo)

        What MANY toxic ingredients are you referring to? I’m always looking to enhance my knowledge base. It’s unfortunate you threw it away, because it is certainly (at worst) MUCH LESS toxic than what most people put on their infants and selves, even if what you say is true. In fact many of my loved ones have had incredible testimonial in curing their children’s’ eczema and rosacea along with other irritating and painful skin conditions using this line. And I stand behind my products and company, I do apologize you were dissatisfied. I hope you would be willing to try our other amazing products in the future and I’d be happy to supply you with ingredient lists as needed. I’d say disgusted is a bit harsh :)

      • hawaiianmojo (to hawaiianmojo)

        WOW! Wake up & Smell the science! Here is a FULL list of toxic chemicals in Arbonne mascara since the reps don’t have the courage to print the m here. Half of the ingredients are not plant based, but rather SYNTHETIC toxins from a “science” based origin. Also, Arbonne has refused repeatedly to answer the GMO question. Would YOU wear GMO ingredients on your skin? Would you ingest them as a “supplement” as Arbonne suggests? I’m NOT putting their crap on my face, thanks!!
        FOOD BABAE – KEEP Kickin butt & sharing successes please :) will let you know how the new mascara I just ordered turns out. It’s not on the list, but hopefully have found a winner!

      • Rita Shelton (to hawaiianmojo)

        My daughter as well as myself, are Arbonne reps..She swears by the ABC baby line. It is the only thing (including a prescription) that has helped my grandson’s eczema ..I love everything I have tried. I really LOVE the mascara , Its a long story..it is amazing..

    • pau;a (to Jane)

      Is propylene glycol or nylon in Arbonne?

      Reply
    • Joy (to Jane)

      Arbonne is not “all natural” unless you consider polyester, PVP, acrylates copolymer, and propylene glycol natural. Better options for mascara is Gabriel, Lauren Brooke Cosmetiques, and Earth’s Beauty. Those are the ones I use and sell based on years of researching cosmetic ingredients. Always read the ingredient lists and be leary of companies or websites that don’t tell you ALL of the ingredients or make it difficult to locate/find them.

      Reply
  15. Helen Siwak

    Are all the mascara’s being discussed cruelty-free? Because being good for humans is great but I also need one that doesn’t kill my furry friends! Thanks, H.

    Reply
  16. Crissi E.

    Sad to see that the Tarte mascara on Amazon has been jacked up to $27 now! :(

    Reply
  17. Ami

    Any eye liners that can be recommended?

    Reply
  18. Amy

    I would love to see you do a review of Bare Minerals make-up – I use their make-up because it is supposed to be…well, “bare minerals” I use it because I was hoping it was a complete like of “safe” make-up which makes life a bit easier. Do you know anything about bare minerals? I love reading your stuff – it keeps me motivated – keep up the good work and thanks!!

    Reply
    • Julie Marhefka-Fisher (to Amy)

      Bare Minerals has parabens in their makeup. I discovered this after I began to “Arbonnize” our home and clean out any skincare with harmful toxins.

      Reply
      • Andria (to Julie Marhefka-Fisher)

        I have looked at several of Bare Minerals products and did not see parabens listed. Can you mention which ones you are referring to?

    • paula (to Amy)

      Bare Minerals has mica

      Reply
  19. hollis

    I just clicked on your link for “Lights Camera Splashes” on Amazon and it’s actually $27.00, not $17 – yikes! I will buy it thought because I am slowly changing over all my make-up as my products run out. It is such a fine line between finances and healthy living, although I know in the long run it will save me money oif I am not sick! I have lots of cnacer in my family, and I have also had difficulty getting pregnant over the last year…now is as good a time as any to try to reverse the last 30+ years of toxicity that I was not even aware of! Thanks for all you do!

    Reply
  20. Jeanette P

    Thank you SO much for posting this and getting your readers to think about what ingredients are in their beauty products!! I wanted to let your readers know about a brand new non toxic, cruelty free, stylish and effective products for your skin and hair called BeautyCounter works with world famous professional make up artists and with the Environmental Working Group (ewg.org) to make all products with the safest ingredients out there! Check them out at http://www.jpohl.beautycounter.com

    DO YOU KNOW WHAT CHEMICALS HIDE IN YOUR COSMETICS??

    *Did you know that 1938 was the last year Federal Law was passed to govern cosmetic safety and protect the people who use them?

    *1300 chemical cosmetics ingredients are banned in the European Union. A mere 11 are banned in the US!!!!! BeautyCounter bans 1500 ingredients!

    Reply
  21. Tanya

    This post is so timely & providential! I’ve been needing to buy some new mascara & knew I needed to research an alternative to the toxic brands, just hadn’t had time to do so. Thank you so much for writing this & helping guide women in the right path to a more healthy lifestyle! BLESSINGS!!!

    Reply
  22. val

    So I bought the organic mascara but do u have suggestions for organic under eye concealer or shampoo??? Thanks!

    Reply
    • Hanna (to val)

      I would like to recommend a really fantastic under eye concealer from Vapor Organics. http://www.vapourbeauty.com/ I thought I would never switch foundations/concealer after years of using Bare Minerals, but I stumbled across this company one very late night and was really curious. They offer a free color consultation and a sample kit for $15 with five samples that you choose. The samples include enough product to really get a feel for it. I switched to Vapour Organics and wont go back to Bare Minerals, products I used and loved for years. I am about to order my fourth under eye concealer and I use both types of foundation they offer. I just like them both and use them for different moods. And you can’t ask for better ingredients 70% organic and 30% natural. They do not offer a mascara yet, but I would try it in a heart beat. Seriously, you have to try it.

      Reply
  23. Lisa

    Howdy Food Babe!
    I enjoyed reading ur post :@)
    As with the food industry, consumers should also be aware of the ingredients that make up our cosmetics, personal care products as well as household items. The FDA regulates the cosmetic industry but it is the companies that are responsible for the safety of their products. At the end of the day, it is really up to the consumer to become better informed and advocate for him or herself if it impacts health. ..in this case mascara. Other ingredients to look out for in mascara include nickel, lead, cadmium and mercury.

    Reply
  24. Lisa

    Is no one actually READING this?
    “Food Babe” suggests a mascara by Tarte, Lights, Camera, Lashes!
    Then she suggests that you check with EWG beauty guide.
    Has anyone else done that??
    ‘um yeah, Tarte was NOT a safe product according to them!
    http://www.ewg.org/skindeep/product/232265/tarte_lights%2C_camera%2C_lashes%21_mascara%2C_Black/
    Check things out of yourself ya’ll!
    & Food Babe, maybe your getting paid by Tarte, but I for one am disappointed in this review.

    Reply
    • Food Babe (to Lisa)

      Lisa – before you go running into the deep end. Check the back of the package of Tarte and you’ll see they have changed their ingredients, since EWG cataloged them. Unfortunately, the best source is the back of the package and then EWG. And no, I’m not getting paid by Tarte.

      Reply
    • Food Babe (to Lisa)

      Also – here are the current ingredients in Tarte (notice the packaging is even updated from the EWG photo). http://tartecosmetics.com/tarte-item-lights-camera-lashes-mascara

      Reply
    • Sheila (to Lisa)

      Lisa, I’m glad you asked that question. I couldn’t find any of her recommended mascaras in the zero or one of Skin Deep’s recommendations. So now I don’t know how to choose a safe one.

      Reply
      • Sheila (to Sheila)

        Replying to myself! I hadn’t seen Food Babe’s reply when I posted my comment! So I guess I will look at the ingredients on the package as Food Babe suggested rather than relying on out of date info on Skin Deep. Sorry Food Babe.

    • Sheila (to Lisa)

      Sorry Food Babe, I had not read your reply to Lisa before making my comment.

      Reply
  25. erica

    vani, what do you think of ZuZu or Gabriel Cosmetics?

    Reply
  26. Hollie

    Hi Girls,

    I have been using Cherry Blooms brush on fiber mascara for over a year now and its great for sensitive eyes! The only ingredients in it are water, beeswax (help with promotion of lash growth and make it super easy to come off with warm water, but strong enough to wear all day), carnuba wax, black iron oxide, nylon 12, stearic acid and natural emulsify agent lanolin. There is no propylene glycol or any other nasty ingredients. It is so nourishing on my lashes the beeswax has definitely made my lashes grow! Worth trying and did I mention how long your lashes get?? 300% longer. yay!

    Reply
  27. A. Mitchell

    I was considering switching to one of these mascara’s at Food Babe’s suggestion. However, after some research I found that both the Tarte mascara and Josie Maran’s contain ingredients that are still hazardous. Josie Maran’s mascara contains Phenoxyethanol. Although it’s been a widely used ingredient, according to several websites, “studies have shown that Phenoxyethanol can be an extreme irritant to the eyes and skin, and can even cause blistering; it is hazardous in the case of ingestion and inhalation as well. The Cosmetic Database rates it as a moderate hazard and notes cancer, allergic reactions, skin, eye and lung irritation, organ and neurotoxicity as possible effects of using products containing Phenoxyethanol. It has shown effects on sensory organs even at low doses, and brain and nervous systems at moderate doses in animals, and causes cell mutation.”

    Tarte’s mascara contains Triethanolamine which “is considered a moderate hazard ingredient by the Cosmetics Database, which notes as concerns. According to Cosmetic Ingredient Review, Association of Occupational and Environmental Clinics, and the U.S. National Library of Medicine, there is strong evidence that Triethanolamine is a human skin, immune system and respiratory toxicant. One or more animal studies show sense organ effects at very low doses, especially when used around the mouth, eyes and lips, and one or more in vitro tests on mammalian cells show positive mutation results. It has been shown to cause bladder and liver cancer, as well as changes in testicles.

    According to OrganicConsumers.org, Triethanolamine can cause allergic reactions including eye problems, dryness of hair and skin, and could be toxic if absorbed into the body over a long period of time. It can cause itching, burning, scaling, hives, and blistering of skin, all symptoms which may increase with higher concentrations (The Green Beauty Guide).”

    According to research, the EPA (Environmental Protection Agency) data sheets show “chromosomal changes and genetic mutation effects in testing as well as testicular atrophy and reproductive damage in mice.”

    The search continues…

    Reply
  28. Olivia Boros

    Hi, can you tell me some eye makeup products (mascara, eyeliner, eye shadow) which does not contain nickel/ iron oxides? I am allergic to nickel and my eyelids get swollen and can’t find makeup products without these ingredients. Thanks!

    Reply
  29. Sara

    I’m surprised tarte is your first choice when that mascara ranks pretty high in hazards on the skin deep site. I recommend people check the ratings on all of these before buying. Anyway thank you for posting the skin deep site it’s a very useful tool!

    Reply
    • stacey griffin (to Sara)

      hey there! I had the same concern, but just noticed that Food Babe already responded to this above. The ingredients have been changed (parabens removed). Hope this helps!

      Reply
  30. Karen

    There is an amazing line of organic make up products called 100% Pure. http://www.100percentpure.com/

    Reply
  31. cycling clothing

    we are pro bicycle wear supplier and offer high quality subaru cycling clothing at the lowest prices. all cycling wear at http://cyclingwear.x10.mx 100% quality guaranteed and free shipping .

    Reply
  32. beyonce album download

    Sweet blog! I found it while browsing on Yahoo News. Do you have any tips on how to get listed in Yahoo
    News? I’ve been trying for a while but I never seem to get there!
    Thank you

    Reply
  33. stacey griffin

    hi there! I received my order of Tarte mascara from amazon today. It is very dry and the consistency is like a clumpy powder. If this is the consistency, it won’t work for me. Please let us know other mascara’s you think are safe that are a little “wetter”, and can be applied with just a few strokes . Thanks!

    Reply
  34. 3ds emulator on pc

    Wow, marvelous blog layout! How long have you been blogging for? you made blogging look easy. The overall look of your web site is great, let alone the content!. Thanks For Your article about Preparing kids for standardized tests

    Reply
  35. Kimberly

    NYR Organic has released it’s mascara – It sold out in the US in less than 24, but the supply will be restocked in February! I was luck enough to order mine and I love it! It smells like cake batter, doesn’t irritate my sensitive eyes, easy to remove, lasts the day and applies easy. I’m a huge mascara skeptic, and even was skeptical of this one, but it had too many rave reviews out of the UK to ignore. The best part is that the mascara is formulated to actually strengthen your natural lashes as you wear it! I’ve never paid $25 for a mascara in my life – but I will never buy a different one after this! http://www.us.nyrorganic.com/shop/kimmers308 It’s not back up on the website yet, but will be back up soon!

    Reply
  36. Jennifer Gallant

    Juice Beauty & Suzanne Somers cosmetic lines are both fabulous!

    Reply
  37. Megan

    Wonderful beat ! I would like to apprentice while you amend your web site, how could i subscribe for a blog website?

    The account helped me a acceptable deal. I had been a little bit acquainted of this your broadcast offered bright clear concept

    Reply
  38. Nancy

    Ecco Bella also has a very nice and safe mascara as well.

    Reply
  39. KTelizabeth

    Wow! After reading these comments I am completely shocked at the number of people who still don’t get it. Just because the company tells you that they are safe or harmless or vegan or whatever marketing words you want to put in there, does not mean anything! I am especially disappointed by the arbonne supporters who clearly don’t get it. It really is about the ingredients and I rarely can even get those disclosed by them.

    As far as mascara goes, The only one I’ve tried on this list is Ava Anderson’s and I truly love it! Now that’s a company who really has your best interest at the forefront and the ingredients tells you that. Her mascara is soft but doesn’t flake. I’ve never had problems with irritated eyes like I use to. In fact I feel like they are healthier and longer than ever. Thanks Food Babe for including it in your list and keep up the good work!

    Reply
  40. Joy

    Mascaras to check out are Earth’s Beauty, Lauren Brooke Cosmetiques and Gabriel. They are some of the cleanest I’ve seen ingredient wise and what I’ve chosen to use personally and sell. The Ava Anderson also looks good though I’ve not tried it.

    Reply
  41. LIssette

    Hey Babe!
    Have you tried any LUSH products?! I absolutely love the company and everything they do! http://www.lushusa.com

    Reply
  42. Women beauty tips

    I found this information about choosing the right mascara, thought it may be useful for you.
    http://www.womentips.co/how-to-choose-the-right-mascara-for-your-eyes/

    Reply

Leave a Reply